A Rally For The Record Books: Will It Last?
Dear Clients,
Here’s an update. I invested 10% of your portfolios in the S&P 500 index on Friday. As such, we participated in yesterday’s rally by adding about +1.5% to the total value of your portfolios. As mentioned in my blog last Thursday, a rally was overdue but did not expect a 10% move. In stock market history, only 2 other days experienced a rally of this proportion or even in the ball park. Both days occurred in bear markets. Yesterday was an anomaly.
The market opened significantly higher again this morning but began to sell-off almost immediately. Based on my indicators, the market is due another day or two of consolidation (sideways or downward action) particularly after such a strong upswing. If the indexes can stabilize, there may be little more upside. But when the rally losses momentum, I suspect the markets will get trounced again as investors focus on the economic backlash caused by frozen credit markets. Even if the credit markets start to function correctly, the economy has already suffered severe damage that will be reflected in the economic data over the weeks and months to come.
With all that said, the extremely oversold conditions presented a trading opportunity, not a long term buying opportunity. Anyway, it may not hurt to nibble a little in here. I may look to add to our current long positions within the next couple of days.
If you are worried about missing the train, you shouldn’t be. Bear market bottoms rarely turn this quickly. We will have ample opportunity to scale into stocks when a new bull market begins. So far, pundits have declared 3 or 4 bottoms that have proven false. There were 6 or 7 false bottoms in the 1929, 1973, and 2000 bear markets. It’s important to keep days like yesterday in perspective. Survey results indicate that the vast majority of private investors chose or were ill advised to remain invested the market despite the economic headwinds. Most non-clients with which I have spoken lost 40-50% of their portfolio values. To use a $100,000 hypothetical example, investors who remained fully invested watched their portfolios deplete from $100,000 to $60,000 in the last 12 months. Naturally, events like yesterday’s enormous rally appeal to human instincts for greed. And, it all sounds incredible until you consider that most people’s tattered hypothetical $60,000 portfolios only increased to $66,000 on the rally. Factually, a future return of 67% is required to climb back from $60,000 to $100,000. Based on S&P 500’s average annual historical return, that objective could take 6-10 years.
By comparison, $100,000 invested in Catamount managed portfolios edged up to approximately $101,000 over the trailing 12 months and gained roughly 1.5% yesterday to end at $102,500. Obviously, smaller percentage gains on a larger capital base can produce significant absolute profits even with a fraction of the exposure.
The key take away: Never allow your portfolio to sustain large losses in a bear market. I’m watching the situation vigilantly.





